Graphical Perception

I’ve been thinking about some talks that I have coming up, like the one at CAP, and decided I should really do a better job describing some of the academic basis for making various design decisions. So I started making a Powerpoint slide (making full use of powerpoint graphics :)) describing the classic paper "Graphical Perception". This paper by Cleveland and McGill in 1984 was one of the first to take a quantitative approach to visualization perception, measuring how well people could estimate various quantities off a graph.

y3m3OxSjzvVD5T f6ZGcwkSfNGlDUOTn6w89EXCmXaxXz1wwec N8CN48uiYZ12qFITl0uJTPxaO8NlCUgXbTBbv DuHYCQdocC6wZiM6i5nYRA HfBzdesMkp6ycVcpSkLp7 ra4C3zugeV A3 SwKiymiLMMOhIpzAbHsjwgrCbk?width=1280&height=720&cropmode=none
Figure 1. My Powerpoint slide describing the Cleveland and McGill Graphical Perception results

The results of these measurements are not surprising, but they do lead to some useful rules of thumb (people measure position well, quantities such as length, direction and angle somewhat worse, area worse than that, and volume and curvature even worse than that and quantities such as color very poorly (thet tested shading and color saturation). You can think of the sequence as corresponding to the dimensionality of the quantities: zero > one > two > three. Color does terribly, but then again given how they were using color at the time, I wouln’t gonsider this a go-to reference on color and perception.

This was a 2D study, but its interesting to think about is how these quantities fare as you go from 2D to 3D. The problem with 3D is that a small thing nearby can seem the same size as a distant large thing (which is basically why infoViz people don’t like 3D). So relative positions scale with distance. Length scales with distance. Area scales with distance squared, volume with distance cubed. Even color depends on the lighting of a 3D scene. But interestingly direction and angle don’t scale with distance at all. Perhaps we should consider using these quantities more in 3D visualizations